Overview:

This transitions web page looks at the larger picture of the similarity between the personalities, lives, and marital relations of John J. Poill and John H. Pyle.

Transitions Synthesis

Theory

L5: Home

Proof that John H. Pyle of AL is John H. Pyle of CA
Category	John H. Pyle – AL	John H. Pyle - CA
Name	Name of John H. Pyle.	Name of John H. Pyle.
Genealogical	Born in Mississippi after 1834. Had a brother named Everett.	Born in Mississippi in 1835. Named a son Everett.
Psychological	Violent person – involved in a stabbing in 1853.	Violent person – killed a person by stabbing in 1870.

Proof that John H. Pyle of CA is John J. Poill of OR
Category	John H. Pyle - CA	John J. Poill
Genealogical	Born in Mississippi in 1835.	Born around 1835. “I was born…in Mississippi.”
Psychological	Violent person – killed a man by stabbing in 1870.	Violent person – Physically and mentally abused his wife Mila Ann on many occasions.
Family Relations	Disserted his family in 1870. Amanda divorced him in 1874.	Deserted his family in 1882; Mila Ann divorced him in 1891.
Migration Patterns	Moved to Yamhill Co, OR 1860 – 1862	Told story of being involved in Confederacy efforts in Yamhill Co, OR during the Civil War.
Westward Ho	Married in Tucson, AZ territory 17 Aug 1859 on the Barnes wagon train from Texas to California on the Butterfield Trail route.	Told stories with many details and accurate place names of the wagon train route from Texas to California coinciding exactly with the Butterfield Trail.
Genealogical Record	No record of him after 1870.	No record of him before 1872.

John J. Poill
Elusive Ancestor Website

Transitions Synthesis

Updated

1/7/2015

thorntongale@poill27.info

Proof that John H. Pyle of AL is John J. Poill of OR
Category	John H. Pyle - AL	John J. Poill
Genealogical	Born in Mississippi after 1834. Proven son of Nicholas Pyle and Mary Ann Westbrook.	Born around 1835. “I was born…in Mississippi. My father’s name was Nick Poil (sic). He married Mary Ann Westbrook.”
Psychological	Violent person – involved in a stabbing in 1853	Violent person – Physically and mentally abused his wife Mila Ann on many occasions severe enough for her to divorce him in 1891.
Genealogical Record	No record of him after 1870.	No record of him before 1872.